I hear this argument all the time
and I heard it the other day. “If you had been born in a different country, you
wouldn’t believe what you do.”
The same logic gets applied in many
different scenarios. The idea of “would have been” is quite popular to many
people. It’s the “if only” philosophy.
If only I had gone to college I
would have a better job now. If only I had been born with better parents I
wouldn’t be as angry as I am. If only I had stayed a virgin I wouldn’t be stuck
with a kid now. If only the other kids hadn’t picked on me in school. If only I
hadn’t lost my sight. If only I could walk again. If only there were such a
thing as would have been.
It wrenches the heart to consider
some of these realities. In some cases the “if only” wished for is something
the speaker had complete control over, it was their own choice. In other cases
it was something done to them. They couldn’t have helped it if they tried.
The problem is there is literally no
way of knowing if the second half of any “if only” statement is even remotely
true. No one can know if you would actually have a better job if you had gone
to college. No one can know if you would be less angry being born with
different parents. No one can know if you would or would not be responsible for
a child right now had you remained a virgin.
Maybe you’re right, but prove it.
I mean this in the most loving way
possible, but there is no way to know what would have been and it does
absolutely no good to dwell on it. There’s no such thing as would have been.